Milk Bar Cereal Milk Ice Cream 14oz Alternatives

Ben & Jerry's Tony Chocolonely Chocolatey Love-a-Fair Ice Cream 16oz
Ben & Jerry's Tony Chocolonely Chocolatey Love-a-Fair Ice Cream 16oz
$6.99
16 oz
Trolli Bursting Crawlers 4.25oz
SALE
Trolli Bursting Crawlers 4.25oz
$2.09$2.79
4.25 oz
Milk Bar Birthday Truffle Crumb Cakes 2ct
Milk Bar Birthday Truffle Crumb Cakes 2ct
$3.79
2 ct
Milk Bar Confetti Cookies 8ct
Milk Bar Confetti Cookies 8ct
$6.49
8 ct
Nestle Toll House Chocolate Chip Cookie Ready to Bake Dough 24ct 16.5oz
Nestle Toll House Chocolate Chip Cookie Ready to Bake Dough 24ct 16.5oz
$4.49
24 ct
Sweet Street Chewy Marshmallow with Brown Butter and Sea Salt Bar 2.1oz
Sweet Street Chewy Marshmallow with Brown Butter and Sea Salt Bar 2.1oz
$2.79
2.1 oz
Nestle Toll House Valentine Chocolate Chip Heart Shape Cookie Dough 16oz
Nestle Toll House Valentine Chocolate Chip Heart Shape Cookie Dough 16oz
$4.99
16 oz
Kinder Bueno Candy Bar 4ct
Kinder Bueno Candy Bar 4ct
$2.49
3 oz
Belgian Boys Raspberry Cookie Tarts 4.4oz
Belgian Boys Raspberry Cookie Tarts 4.4oz
$6.99
4.4 oz
Jelly Belly Fruit Bowl Jelly Beans 3.5oz
Jelly Belly Fruit Bowl Jelly Beans 3.5oz
$3.79
3.5 oz
Trolli Original Sour Brite Crawlers Limited Edition 5oz
SALE
Trolli Original Sour Brite Crawlers Limited Edition 5oz
$2.09$2.79
5 oz
Sweet Street Salted Caramel Manifesto Cookie 2.8oz
Sweet Street Salted Caramel Manifesto Cookie 2.8oz
$2.49
2.8 oz
SweeTARTS Gummies Fruity Splitz 9oz
SweeTARTS Gummies Fruity Splitz 9oz
$4.49
9 oz
Trolli Sour Brite Eggs Gummy Candy 4oz
SALE
Trolli Sour Brite Eggs Gummy Candy 4oz
$2.02$2.69
4 oz
Emerald Glazed Pecans 5oz
Emerald Glazed Pecans 5oz
$4.89
5 oz
Reese's Peanut Butter Hearts King Size 2.4oz
Reese's Peanut Butter Hearts King Size 2.4oz
$2.29
2.4 oz
Smucker's Frozen Uncrustables PB & Strawberry on Wheat 1ct 2.6oz
Smucker's Frozen Uncrustables PB & Strawberry on Wheat 1ct 2.6oz
$1.39
2.6 oz
Sheila G's Chocolate Chip Brownie Brittle 5oz
Sheila G's Chocolate Chip Brownie Brittle 5oz
$5.99
5 oz
Hostess Chocolate CupCakes Single Serve 2ct
Hostess Chocolate CupCakes Single Serve 2ct
$3.29
2 ct
Betty Crocker Fudge Brownie Mix 18.3oz
Betty Crocker Fudge Brownie Mix 18.3oz
$2.99
18.3 oz
Mountain Valley Spring Water Spring Glass Bottle 1L
Mountain Valley Spring Water Spring Glass Bottle 1L
$3.49
SweeTARTS Valentine's Punch Twisted Ropes 3oz
SweeTARTS Valentine's Punch Twisted Ropes 3oz
$2.49
3 oz
Oreo Cakesters 10.1oz
Oreo Cakesters 10.1oz
$6.49
10.1 oz
Cheetos Crunchy Mexican Street Corn 8.5oz
Cheetos Crunchy Mexican Street Corn 8.5oz
$5.19
8.5 oz
Ferrero Rocher Hazelnut Chocolate Candy 1.3oz
Ferrero Rocher Hazelnut Chocolate Candy 1.3oz
$2.49
1.3 oz
Boyer Mallo Cups 1.5oz
Boyer Mallo Cups 1.5oz
$2.49
1.5 oz
Now & Later Morphs Fruit Chews 3.5oz
Now & Later Morphs Fruit Chews 3.5oz
$2.49
3.5 oz
Trolli Sour Brite Crawlers Gummy Candy 9oz
SALE
Trolli Sour Brite Crawlers Gummy Candy 9oz
$3.07$4.09
9 oz
Smartfood Caramel & Cheddar Mix Popcorn 7oz
Smartfood Caramel & Cheddar Mix Popcorn 7oz
$4.99
7 oz
Ruffles Baked Cheddar & Sour Cream Potato Chips 6.25oz
Ruffles Baked Cheddar & Sour Cream Potato Chips 6.25oz
$3.99
6.25 oz
Basically, 24ct 16.9oz Btls Purified Water
Basically, 24ct 16.9oz Btls Purified Water
$5.49
24 ct
Sweet Street Gluten Free Honduran Chocolate Manifesto Brownie 2.8 oz
Sweet Street Gluten Free Honduran Chocolate Manifesto Brownie 2.8 oz
$2.79
2.8 oz
Nerds Gummy Clusters Candy 8oz
Nerds Gummy Clusters Candy 8oz
$5.89
8 oz
Trolli Very Berry Sour Brite Crawlers Limited Edition 5oz
SALE
Trolli Very Berry Sour Brite Crawlers Limited Edition 5oz
$2.09$2.79
5 oz
Trolli Peachie Os Gummy Candy 4.25oz
SALE
Trolli Peachie Os Gummy Candy 4.25oz
$2.02$2.69
4.25 oz
SweeTARTS Watermelon Berry Collision Ropes 3.5oz
SweeTARTS Watermelon Berry Collision Ropes 3.5oz
$2.49
3.5 oz
Petit Pot Dark Chocolate Organic French Dessert 2 PK
Petit Pot Dark Chocolate Organic French Dessert 2 PK
$6.99
Good Eat'n Carolina Style BBQ Popcorn 4.5oz Bag
Good Eat'n Carolina Style BBQ Popcorn 4.5oz Bag
$3.79
4.5 oz
Organic Valley Whole Milk 1/2 Gallon
Organic Valley Whole Milk 1/2 Gallon
$5.99
0.5 gal
Brach's Tiny Conversation Hearts 7oz
Brach's Tiny Conversation Hearts 7oz
$3.29
7 oz
Walkers Pure Butter Shortbread Fingers 5.3oz
Walkers Pure Butter Shortbread Fingers 5.3oz
$8.49
5.3 oz
Lindt Lindor Assorted Chocolate Truffles 5.1oz Bag
Lindt Lindor Assorted Chocolate Truffles 5.1oz Bag
$5.99
5.1 oz
Tony's Chocolonely 42% Dark Milk Chocolate with Pretzel and Toffee Bar 6.35oz
Tony's Chocolonely 42% Dark Milk Chocolate with Pretzel and Toffee Bar 6.35oz
$6.49
6.35 oz
PopCorners White Cheddar 7oz
PopCorners White Cheddar 7oz
$4.29
7 oz
Reese's Dipped Pretzels 4.25oz
Reese's Dipped Pretzels 4.25oz
$3.29
4.25 oz
Kellogg's Rice Krispies Treats Original Crispy Marshmallow Squares 2.2oz
Kellogg's Rice Krispies Treats Original Crispy Marshmallow Squares 2.2oz
$2.29
2.2 oz
Hi-Chew Sweet & Sour Assorted Fruity Chewy Candy 3.17oz
Hi-Chew Sweet & Sour Assorted Fruity Chewy Candy 3.17oz
$2.79
3.17 oz
Angie's Boomchickapop Sweet & Salty Kettle Corn 10oz
Angie's Boomchickapop Sweet & Salty Kettle Corn 10oz
$5.99
10 oz
Butterfinger Bar King Size 3.7oz
Butterfinger Bar King Size 3.7oz
$2.49
3.7 oz
Smucker's Frozen Uncrustables PB & Grape Jelly on Wheat 1ct 2.6oz
Smucker's Frozen Uncrustables PB & Grape Jelly on Wheat 1ct 2.6oz
$1.39
2.6 oz
Sweet Street Sandy's Amazing Chocolate Chunk Manifesto Cookie 2.8oz
Sweet Street Sandy's Amazing Chocolate Chunk Manifesto Cookie 2.8oz
$2.49
2.8 oz
Good Eat'n Hot Hot Puffs 5oz Bag
Good Eat'n Hot Hot Puffs 5oz Bag
$3.99
5 oz
Simply Cheetos Puffs White Cheddar 8.5oz
Simply Cheetos Puffs White Cheddar 8.5oz
$4.99
8 oz
OLIPOP Classic Root Beer 12oz Can
OLIPOP Classic Root Beer 12oz Can
$2.79
12 oz
Good Eat'n Cinnamon Sugar Mini Donut Puffs 6oz Bag
Good Eat'n Cinnamon Sugar Mini Donut Puffs 6oz Bag
$3.99
6 oz
Hostess Birthday CupCakes Single Serve 2ct
Hostess Birthday CupCakes Single Serve 2ct
$3.29
2 ct
Reese's Thins Milk Chocolate Peanut Butter Cups 3.1oz
Reese's Thins Milk Chocolate Peanut Butter Cups 3.1oz
$2.49
3.1 oz
M&Ms Crunchy Cookie Candies Share Size 2.83oz
M&Ms Crunchy Cookie Candies Share Size 2.83oz
$2.49
2.83 oz
Fruit Gushers Flavor Mixer 4.25oz
Fruit Gushers Flavor Mixer 4.25oz
$4.99
4.25 oz
Andy Capp's Hot Fries 3oz
Andy Capp's Hot Fries 3oz
$2.29
3 oz
Glico Pocky Matcha Tea Biscuit Sticks 1.41oz
Glico Pocky Matcha Tea Biscuit Sticks 1.41oz
$3.99
1.41 oz
SunChips Garden Salsa 7oz
SunChips Garden Salsa 7oz
$4.19
7 oz
Haribo Sour S'ghetti Gummi Candy 5oz
Haribo Sour S'ghetti Gummi Candy 5oz
$2.49
5 oz
Reddi-wip Original Whipped Cream 6.5oz
Reddi-wip Original Whipped Cream 6.5oz
$4.99
6.5 oz
Fruit By The Foot Raspberry Lemonade & Blue Raspberry Fruit Snack King Size 2.5oz
Fruit By The Foot Raspberry Lemonade & Blue Raspberry Fruit Snack King Size 2.5oz
$2.29
2.5 oz
Tony's Chocolonely 32% Caramel & Sea Salt Milk Chocolate Bar 6.35oz
Tony's Chocolonely 32% Caramel & Sea Salt Milk Chocolate Bar 6.35oz
$6.49
6.35 oz
Reese's Take 5 Chocolate Peanut Butter Bar King Size 3.1oz
Reese's Take 5 Chocolate Peanut Butter Bar King Size 3.1oz
$2.29
3.1 oz
Oreo Mini Chocolate Sandwich Cookies 8oz
Oreo Mini Chocolate Sandwich Cookies 8oz
$3.49
8 oz
Nunbelievable Peanut Butter Artisanal Cookie 3oz
BLACK OWNED
Nunbelievable Peanut Butter Artisanal Cookie 3oz
$2.79
3 oz
Haribo Sweet & Sour Twin Snakes Gummi Candy 5oz
Haribo Sweet & Sour Twin Snakes Gummi Candy 5oz
$2.49
5 oz
Basically, Amazing Sweet & Salty Trail Mix 5oz
Basically, Amazing Sweet & Salty Trail Mix 5oz
$3.49
5 oz
Lay's Baked Original Potato Chips 6.25oz
Lay's Baked Original Potato Chips 6.25oz
$3.99
6.25 oz